A former Conn Smythe winner claims that McDavid is a bad role model for kids

PUBLICATION

Sam Jones
July 11, 2024 (4:13 PM)

SHARE THIS STORY

In the intense aftermath of the Stanley Cup Finals, Connor McDavid, despite his extraordinary playoff performance, found himself at the center of a controversy that extends beyond the rink. For the first time since J.S.

Giguere in 2003, a player from the losing team, McDavid, won the prestigious Conn Smythe Trophy. However, his decision to not publicly accept the award has sparked a debate that echoes beyond the boundaries of the game.

"I do think that he should have gone and accepted the Trophy. At the end of the day I think the game is always bigger than the individual. This is a major trophy for the NHL. It would've showed kids, I guess, that winning or losing you still present yourself the right way.» - JS Giguere

This statement from former NHL goalie J.S. Giguere captures the traditional viewpoint that values sportsmanship and the ceremonial aspects of the game. Giguere, who experienced a similar situation, criticized McDavid for not setting what he perceives as a good example for young fans watching the game

The decision has left fans and commentators divided. While some echo Giguere's sentiments, emphasizing the importance of upholding traditions and demonstrating grace in defeat, others advocate for McDavid's choice to prioritize his emotional state and team unity over protocol.

In a poignant display of camaraderie, instead of stepping out to accept his individual accolade, McDavid chose to remain in the locker room with his teammates, sharing in the collective heartbreak of a season-ending defeat. Reports highlighted this moment as an emotional one for the entire Oilers team, with McDavid showing leadership by staying with his team rather than participating in a ceremonial accolade alone

This action, arguably, presents a different kind of role model to young fans: one that values team over individual achievements, and emotional authenticity over ceremonial expectations. McDavid's performance throughout the playoffs, his dedication to his team, and his handling of the loss may very well have taught a more profound lesson about the spirit of teamwork and the depths of dedication required in professional sports.

As debates swirl around the appropriateness of McDavid's actions, one thing remains clear: his impact on the game and on his team is indisputable. While he did not stand to accept the Conn Smythe Trophy this year, his leadership and skill continue to promise great potential for future seasons.

Perhaps, in another run at the Stanley Cup, McDavid will have a chance not only to claim victory but also to redefine what true sportsmanship can look like in the eyes of the next generation of hockey fans.

Source: TheLeafsNation on X

Giguere speaks on McDavid again