An insider says Marner Matthews era is coming to an end in Toronto

PUBLICATION

Sam Jones
April 28, 2024 (5:07 PM)

SHARE THIS STORY

Last night's Game 4 showcased a deeply troubling performance by the Toronto Maple Leafs, one that might just signal the demise of the current team's framework. The dismal show was not only disappointing but also marked by a visible discord among the team's star players, casting a shadow on their future prospects.

After eight years and several playoff appearances, this core group, despite considerable investment, has managed to advance beyond the first round only once. That sole occasion, last season against the Florida Panthers, ended in a lackluster defeat, with the Leafs bowing out in five games. The recent display further underscores a troubling pattern of underachievement that has plagued the team during critical moments.

During the game, a rare and concerning scene unfolded as key players including Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, and William Nylander openly displayed frustration with each other. This culminated in Marner exhibiting an outburst reminiscent of a child's tantrum. Such public displays of discontent suggest deep-seated issues within the team dynamics, hinting at cracks in the Leafs' foundational ethos.

Team captain John Tavares attempted to frame the friction as a positive force, suggesting it was merely a sign of players pushing each other to excel.

«A lot of guys have been here for a while,» said Tavares, before characterizing it as an example of how his teammates continue to push each other.

Conversely, Marner downplayed the severity of the bench incident.

«I don't think there's any (frustration),» said Marner. «We're grown men. We were talking about plays out there that we just want to make sure we're all 100 percent on and know what we're doing.

Despite these reassurances, the overarching narrative remains one of a team struggling to translate regular-season competence into playoff success. With the recent appointment of Keith Pelley as the new CEO of MLSE, the entire executive from Brendan Shanahan to head coach Sheldon Keefe and the coaching staff are under scrutiny. The pressure is mounting, especially with the possibility of another unremarkable exit looming this round.

As the Leafs face these critical challenges, the organization might be compelled to consider significant changes, lest the current structure proves definitively untenable in pursuing the coveted Stanley Cup.