Staff effectiveness is called into doubt by Skinner's new coaching
Stuart Skinner's decision to change goalie coaches marks a pivotal shift in the Edmonton Oilers' approach, reflecting a broader trend towards prioritizing mental fitness and modern training techniques in hockey.
This change comes after Skinner's inconsistent performances, where his challenges were more mental than technical, as he himself admitted the pressure in critical moments often overwhelmed him.
Initially under the guidance of Oilers' long-standing goalie coach, Dustin Schwartz, Skinner's stats were less than stellar, with a save percentage of only .793 across the first three games of the season. The numbers, albeit dismal, only tell part of the story. The true change occurred when Skinner took a bold step to work with Adam Francilia, focusing on the psychological aspects of goaltending. The improvement was immediate and tangible, as evidenced by his .906 save percentage in the subsequent two games, a crucial factor in keeping the Oilers' hopes alive in the playoffs.
Skinner's progress didn't stop there. In a standout performance against one of the league's top offenses, he boasted a .939 save percentage, showcasing his potential when mentally attuned. This raises a significant question: with both Skinner and Jack Campbell opting for external goalie coaching, what remains the role for Schwartz within the organization?
Schwartz, known for his traditional coaching methods, seems increasingly out of step with the needs of modern NHL goalies. His techniques, which may suit veteran players, fail to incorporate the crucial elements of sports psychology that are essential for younger athletes facing the high pressures of professional hockey. With Skinner and Campbell looking outside the organization for guidance, and Schwartz only continuing to work with Calvin Pickard, whose style aligns with older methodologies, one must ponder the efficacy and relevance of Schwartz's continued employment with the Oilers.
As the Oilers navigate this transitional phase, the shift towards modernizing their coaching staff, particularly for such a crucial position as the goalie, seems not just necessary but inevitable. The decision could define the team's future successes and align their strategies with the evolving demands of professional hockey.
| POLL | ||
Do the Oilers think Schwartz should be replaced? | ||
| Yes, he needs to go | 30 | 88.2 % |
| No, keep both and run with it | 4 | 11.8 % |
| List of polls | ||
