According to Frank Seravalli from Daily Faceoff, the Oilers fans hold Skinner in high regard when you compare to the rest of the league.
Frank Seravalli noted that Skinner's play is not consistent at all and he has stretches where he performs like a top-tier goalie followed by games where he struggles. This lack of consistency is why he isn't viewed as good as everybody thinks by the hockey community.
Matt Larkin from Daily Faceoff also remarked that the Oilers' performance last season correlated directly with their goaltenders' save percentages. Despite the Oilers maintaining a strong expected goals-for percentage at 5-on-5, Stuart Skinner's game significantly impacted their results.
Frank Seravalli discussed the pressure on Skinner to balance his highs and lows and suggested that experience could help Skinner improve his overall consistency. He also mentioned how the Oilers' powerful offense could occasionally struggle to score and during those moments, the team expects their goalie to step up and this is something Skinner has some issues with.
The Oilers' high aspirations this season, which is a potential return to the Stanley Cup Final, and it will depend on Skinner reaching a ceiling in his game.